The report that started the ball rolling is an official JEDEC presentation from Alvin Cox, Chairman of the SSD subcommittee, and the claims of potentially poor data retention made therein have caused much chatter across the net.
This is highly technical topic and one which is, quite frankly, well outside my level of expertise. However, after exhaustive research, I’ve come to the following conclusion:
Essentially, if an SSD remains connected to the power source, as in connected to a PC, there is nothing to worry about. Considering the expense involved, I’m not sure who would want to utilize SSDs for offline storage purposes anyway, but even under these circumstances, the parameters required in Mr. Cox’s report for data loss to occur represent an unlikely scenario.
I suggest reading the in-depth rebuttal article presented by Kristian Vättö over at AnandTech here: The Truth About SSD Data Retention.
Essentially, Kristian Vättö’s conclusions are encapsulated within the following couple of excerpts:
- Worst case scenario, the data retention can be as short as one week, which is what many sites have touted with their “data loss in matter of days” claims. Yes, it can technically happen, but not in typical client environment.
- All in all, there is absolutely zero reason to worry about SSD data retention in typical client environment. Remember that the figures presented here [in the report] are for a drive that has already passed its endurance rating, so for new drives the data retention is considerably higher, typically over ten years for MLC NAND based SSDs. If you buy a drive today and stash it away, the drive itself will become totally obsolete quicker than it will lose its data.
I believe this is yet another case of so-called tech writers sacrificing the truth in favor of a headline.
Kudos to Kristian Vättö
3 thoughts on “Stored SSDs Will Lose Data In a Matter of Days – BS or Not”
I think you are right Dave – it’s just a load of hyped up BS by some tech writers wanting to grab the headlines! Besides, if you are savvy enough to have made System Images and /or Custom Refresh images and stored them on a standard HD, then you will always be able to recover from any data loss the SSD MIGHT eventually suffer!
All hype and no show.
Sounds a bit like Yahoo and Fox news.
The headline says one thing and then when you finish reading the article it had nothing to do with the headline.
Like a sale at the supermarket to get you there hoping you’ll buy the expensive stuff too.
Thanks for the article……….Alan
So help me please. Is it safe to store data on a Flashdrive and SSDD? Yes or no.
Comments are closed.